top of page

Terri Lynn's

Cafe & Catering

133 East Market Street
New Albany, IN 47150

Party Express
Hors d'oeuvres Trays
PLEASE ORDER WELL IN ADVANCE (the sooner the better!)


Our hors d'oeuvres selections can be displayed on our disposable black trays or you can bring your trays to us a day or two before your pick up.   Some items include a serving tray and some do not.  Please read carefully. Also, some items have a minimum purchase and some require more than a 36 hour notice.  When picking up your order, please park in the alley next to the Cafe and call to let us know you have arrived. We will bring your order out to you. (Look for the sign on the side of the building.)
***PLEASE NOTE - It is very important that you arrive for pick up at your scheduled time. If you cannot be at the Cafe by your scheduled time, please call to let us know. Also if you need to come early, please call to ensure that your order is ready. We run a tight schedule!!

Fall 2022 - Winter 2023


(crackers are not included)
     serves 70+         serves 50 +            serves 20+

     Large $85       Medium  $65         Small $45

Cheddar Pecan Cheese Torte 

topped with Cranberry Coulis 

Bleu Cheese and Walnut Torte

topped with Apple Chutney
Cheddar Jalapeno and Pepita Torte 

topped with Jalapeno Jam 


    serves 70+         serves 50 +            serves 20+

    Large $100       Medium  $80         Small $60

Pumpkin Seed, White Cheddar & Sage Chees Torte

topped with Apple Chutney

Sun Dried Tomato & Basil Pesto Cheese Torte

topped with Tomato Jam

Goat Cheese and Pistachio Cheese Torte

topped with Apricot Fig Jam Compote


Cheese Cube Display with Fresh Fruit Garnish
assorted cheese cubes displayed on a black tray decorated with grapes and kiwi. Includes our entertainment crackers.

Small Tray         $  45   15 - 20 guests

Medium Tray     $  88   30 - 35 guests

Large Tray         $100   40 - 45 guests

Exotic Cheese Display 

brie wedges with raspberry coulis, bleu cheese wedges with walnut confetti, goat cheese with spicy tomato jam, mozzarella balls with sun dried tomato confetti, at least three hard cheeses, grapes, berries, dried fruit, dried nuts and assorted gourmet crackers.

Small Tray          $   95  15 - 20 guests

Medium Tray      $ 165  30 - 35 guests

Large Tray          $ 220  40 - 45 guests

Fresh Fruit Display 

chunks of pineapple, honeydew, cantaloupe, strawberries, clusters of grapes and a kiwi star displayed on a tray

Small Tray          $  65   20 - 25 guests

Medium Tray      $  96   35 - 40 guests

Large Tray          $130   45 - 50 guests


Dips by the Pint

Fresh Basil and Tomato Bruschetta  $14/pint
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus $9/pint

Classic Hummus $8/pint

Black Bean and Corn Salsa $11/pint

Cilantro Lime Salsa $10/pint

Guacamole $14/pint

Charcuterie Display

(minimum 3 day notice, please )

an amazing assortment of cured meats, hard cheeses, soft cheeses, dried fruit, nuts, fresh fruit, mixed pitted olives, mini sweet pickles, mini dill pickles and sweet & savory spreads served with assorted gourmet crackers.

Small              $108   15 - 20 guests

Medium          $185   30 - 35 guests

Large              $240   40 - 45 guests

Loaded Hummus with Pita Chips
Classic hummus drizzled with olive oil and sprinkled with our Tuscan seasoning blend and garnished with cucumber, tomatoes, kalamata olives and crumbled feta. Price includes pita chips

Small Tray        $  56   15 - 20 guests

Medium Tray    $  96   30 - 35 guests

Large Tray        $125   40 - 45 guests

Marinated Mediterranean Display

such wonderful things as marinated asparagus tips, grape tomatoes, artichokes, pepperoni, olives, zucchini strips, red pepper strips, tortellini and marinated cheeses

Small Tray           $  75  15 - 20 guests

Medium Tray       $130  30 - 35 guests

Large Tray           $170  40 - 45 guests

Mediterranean Shrimp Cocktail   

market price/quart  (2 qt. minimum)

a wonderful combination of shrimp, cucumbers, kalamata olives and tomatoes.  (Serve this in a large bowl with pita chips; or for an elegant touch, serve in shooter glasses.  Price does not include chips.)

9 Layer Fiesta Dip with Tortilla Chips

re-fried beans, southwest cream cheese, lettuce, cheese, tomatoes, green onions, black olives and jalapeño peppers layered and topped with our cilantro lime salsa. Price includes chips

Small Tray          $  45   15 - 20 guests

Medium Tray      $  79   30 - 35 guests

Large Tray          $101   40 - 45 guests

Mexican Shrimp Cocktail   

market price/quart    (2 qt. minimum)

a wonderful combination of shrimp, avocado, cucumber, cilantro, tomatoes, onions and peppers.  (Serve in a large bowl with chips; or for an elegant touch, serve in shooter glasses. Price does not include chips.)

Peeled Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail -  market price

(2 pound minimum)

served with choice of 1 dip:

cranberry chipotle cocktail sauce, horseradish sauce, plain cocktail sauce, lemon caper aioli, or creamy pesto

Marinated Skewers   $2.75 each

(2 dz. minimum of each flavor)
    Tortellini, Black Olive and Grape Tomatoes
    Tortellini, Green Olive and Cheese Cube
    Grape Tomato, Mozzarella and Black Olive


    Tortellini, Pepperoni and Cheese Cube 

Fresh Vegetable Crudite Display with Dip

Assorted seasonal crudités creatively displayed and served with choice of peppercorn or creamy garden ranch dip. 

Small Tray       $45     20 - 25 guests

Medium Tray   $72     35 - 40 guests

Large Tray       $90     45 - 50 guests


CANAPES (does not include serving tray)

(minimum of 3 dozen of each flavor)

If you are picking up and not serving until later, we will pack components separately for you to assemble just prior to serving

Roast Beef on a Sliced Baguette with                $18/dozen

       Gorgonzola Aioli and Tomato Jam

       Roasted Red Pepper Aioli


Pork Tenderloin on a Sliced Baguette with         $18/dozen

        Garlic Aioli and Bourbon Peach Chutney

        Roasted Red Pepper Aioli

BLT on Toast Rounds with Garlic Aioli            $18/dozen

Benedictine on Rye Toast Rounds with Bacon $17/dozen

Goat Cheese, Apricot Jam and Pistachio Crostini $14/dozen

Mini Savory Phyllo Tarts $14/dozen 

(does not include serving tray)

(minimum of 3 dozen of each flavor)

If you are picking up, we will pack shells separately from filling for you to assemble just prior to serving
Rosemary Chicken Salad

Derby Chicken with Swiss and Bacon

Fresh Basil, Tomato and Mozzarella

Spinach, Feta and Sun Dried Tomatoes

Goat Cheese and Fig Jam with Pistachios

Tortilla Pinwheels (vegetarian) $15/roll 

(does not include serving tray)

(minimum of 3 rolls of each flavor)

Black Bean, Red Pepper and Cumin Scented Cream Cheese

Spinach, Sun Dried Tomato and Feta Herb Cream Cheese

Spinach, Cranberry, Feta and Herb Cream Cheese

Roasted Red Pepper Veggie Cream Cheese

Olive, Sun Dried Tomato, Basil Pesto and Feta Cream Cheese


Tortilla Pinwheels (with meat) $18/roll 

(does not include serving tray)

(minimum of 3 rolls of each flavor)

Mesquite Turkey with Cranberry Cream Cheese
Caesar Chicken with Sun Dried Tomatoes and Parmesan 
Ham and Swiss with Dijon Cream Cheese
Spicy Chicken and Green Chile Cream Cheese

Spicy Pork and Pico de Gallo Cream Cheese




All sandwiches are packed in a foil container.

They can be displayed on black trays for $5 per tray.

(We use 4 of our Cafe croissants cut into 3rd's to yield

1 dozen cocktail size sandwiches)

Marinated & Slow Roasted Pork Tenderloin*

    $28/dozen on Mini Yeast Rolls

    $34/dozen on Croissants 

    with Apple Chutney Aioli

     with Basil Garlic Aioli 

     with Roasted Red Pepper Aioli

     with Maple Bourbon Mustard Sauce

* 3 dozen minimum

Slow Roasted Beef Round*   

    $36/dozen on Mini Yeast Rolls

    $34/dozen on Croissants 

        with Roasted Red Pepper Aioli

        with Gorgonzola Aioli

        with Horseradish Sauce

* 3 dozen minimum

Glazed Ham with Maple Bourbon Mustard Sauce

    $24/dozen on Mini Yeast Rolls

    $28/dozen on Croissants 


Turkey with Cranberry Mayo

     $28/dozen on Mini Yeast Rolls
     $32/dozen on Croissants 


Terri Lynn`s Rosemary Chicken Salad


       $28/dozen on Mini Yeast Rolls

       $32/dozen on Croissants 



(Old fashioned crust less sandwiches. Please order a minimum of 2 dozen of each flavor)

Benedictine $16/dozen                      

Pimento Cheese $14/dozen

Cranberry Cream Cheese $12/dozen

Olive Cream Cheese $12/dozen


Tuna Salad $22/dozen

Egg Salad $20/dozen

Chicken Salad $24/dozen

Salmon & Dill Spread $25/dozen

All sandwiches are packed in a foil container.

They can be displayed on black trays for $5 per tray.


(2 quart minimum on all dips)

(Price does not include chips or crackers)

Spinach & Jalapeño Con Queso $16/quart

Spinach, Artichoke and Roasted Red Pepper Fondue $18/quart


Baked Fiesta Corn and Green Chile Dip $18/quart

Baked Spinach, Tomato and Artichoke Dip $18/quart

Baked Spinach, Butternut Squash & Gruyere $19/quart


Baked Caramelized Onion, Bacon

                      and Gruyere Dip $20/quart 
Baked Sicilian Pepperoni and Olive Dip $22/quart
Baked Kentucky Hot Brown Dip $22/quart


Baked Brie en Croute $50 (will serve 35- 40 guests)

    Apricot Almond            

    Balsamic Honey Pecan 

    Apple Chutney

    Cranberry Coulis

Stuffed Mushrooms $18/ dozen 

(minimum of 4 dozen of each flavor)    

Bleu cheese and walnut
Spinach, feta and sun dried tomato

Spinach, artichoke and gruyere

Parmesan, sage bread crumb

Spinach, cream cheese and bacon

Chorizo sausage and cornbread
Italian sausage and bread crumb

Lump crab and parmesan  market price
Glazed Chicken Tenders $3 

(We like to cut these into 3 bite sized pieces before marinating and cooking. We suggest 1 tender or 3 bites per person) 


(Minimum of 1 dozen of each flavor)

     Kentucky Bourbon Glaze

     Margarita Lime

     Sesame Teriyaki

     Apricot Mustard

     Cranberry Madeira    



Quesadillas served with Sour Cream & Salsa

(minimum of 4 dozen of each flavor)
Black bean, corn and rice with co-jack cheese $16/dozen


Southwest chicken, green chile & colby jack $20/dozen

Ancho chile steak, peppers, onions & 

                       pepper jack cheese $32/dozen 

Cilantro lime shrimp with queso fresco      $32/dozen 

Warm Sliders

Hot Brown (turkey, bacon, swiss and tomato) $36/dozen

Ham and Swiss   $30/dozen

Italian Ham & Salami $34/dozen

Frittata Triangles $70/pan (96 bite sized pieces) 

Similar to quiche and GLUTEN FREE!!! Eggs and potatoes are combined with meats and cheeses for this Italian delight. 
     Spinach, Diced Tomatoes and Asiago    


     Sausage, Diced Tomatoes and Cheddar      

     Bacon and Cheddar 

     Ham, Mushrooms and Gruyere

     Green Chiles, Chorizo Sausage, Diced Tomatoes

             and Cojack ​​


Savory Strudels $60/braid

(@ 32 bite sized pieces)
Cranberry, balsamic, walnut and brie

Tomato bruschetta, mozzarella and parmesan 

Spinach, wild mushroom, butternut squash and gruyere


Italian sausage, spinach, cremini mushrooms

       and asiago cheese

Tuscan chicken with green olives, sun dried tomatoes,

        spinach and pepperoncini

Caesar chicken with parmesan and tomatoes 
Prosciutto, goat cheese and apricot fig jam

Meatballs $15/pound (approx. 32 per pound)
Honey barbecue glazed

Bourbon brown sugar glazed

Cranberry Glazed


(minimum of 4 dozen of each flavor)
Black Bean Corn Cakes  $24/dozen

         served with chipotle dipping sauce

Mini Zucchini Corn Cakes $24/dozen

         served with tomato jam  

Mini Basil-Parmesan Lump Crab Cakes -market price-

         served with roasted red pepper aioli


(does not include a serving bowl)

Tostios White Tortilla Chips $7/pound

Entertainment Crackers $4/sleeve

Stacy's Pita Chips $10/18 oz. bag 

Stacy's Bagel Crisps $6/3 oz. bag

Toasted Baguette Slices (plain) $6/loaf

Toasted Baguette Slices (garlic)$7/loaf



(sold in half pint containers)

Orange Poppy Seed Dressing   $7

Parmesan Peppercorn Dressing  $8

Creamy Jalapeno Dressing   $7

Balsamic Vinaigrette    $7

Honey Mustard Sauce   $7

Creamy Ranch Dressing   $7

Creamy Basil Pesto Aioli   $8
Roasted Red Pepper Aioli   $9
Bourbon Barbecue Sauce   $9

Henry Bains Sauce   $10

Creamy Horseradish   $8

Apple Chutney  $10

Tomato Jam  $10


(minimum 2 dz. each flavor)

Shrimp Shooters     market price  

     Mexican, Greek, or Asian

Salsa Shooters     

     Basil & Tomato Bruschetta  $3.50/each

     Black Bean and Corn $2.75/each 

     Cilantro Lime Salsa $2/each

Dessert Shooters $4/each 

     Cranberry Eggnog Trifle

     Pumpkin Gingersnap Trifle

     Heath Toffee Crunch Trifle 

Charcuterie Cups  $7/each


                    = vegetarian

bottom of page