top of page

Terri Lynn's

Cafe & Catering

133 East Market Street
New Albany, IN 47150

Fall 2023 &Winter 2024

Dinner Pick Up Menus
48 hour minimum notice




(the sooner the better!)





We understand the need for last minute bereavement meals and items for a sick friend. We will do our very best to accommodate these situations.

Some items on this menu do require a longer lead time due to the nature of the product or cooking process. 

Turkey and beef roast require at least a 3 day notice and all orders are subject to availability on our calendar.

Catering Pick Up Orders

Party trays and dinner items can be picked up from our cafe 

Monday 8 a.m. - Noon

Tuesday thru Friday 8 a.m. - 2:30 p.m.

Saturday 9 a.m. - Noon*

(*occasional exceptions may 

be made for large orders)


SIDE DISHES            
                              PREMIUM    REGULAR   

Family serves 6 - 8       $28         $20

Small serves 12 - 15     $55         $40

Large serves 24 - 30     $110        $80


Sautéed Green Beans  
    with balsamic bacon and shallots
     with thyme, roasted butternut squash and walnuts

Bourbon Smashed Sweet Potatoes

    with Pecan Praline topping and marshmallows  

Italian Vegetable Medley  
 squash, zucchini, red pepper, red onion in

     a lemon basil butter sauce
Broccoli Casserole with cracker crumb topping

Gruyere Potato Gratin

Cheddar Bacon Ranch Potato Gratin

Tomato, Zucchini & Three Cheese Strata

TLC Rotini Mac & Cheese      


Smashed Red Skin Potatoes 
     parmesan garlic        cheddar ranch   Sautéed G
reen Beans       
     with fresh rosemary    

     with lemon and dill     

     with garlic & shallots
Kentucky Corn Pudding

Sage dressing

Slow cooked Sweet Potatoes

     with butter and brown sugar

Herb Roasted Potatoes with Shallots
Southern Style Green Beans with Ham       Baby Carrots

     with honey butter    with lemon dill butter 

Mini Yeast Pan Rolls (24 ct.)           $10/pan
Parisian Bread (plain and multigrain)  $8/loaf
Petite Buns (for Barbecue) $7/dozen 

Specialty Salads
Signature Pasta    $12/qt.
Pasta of the Day   $12/qt.
Potato Salad of the Day $12/qt.
Cucumber Salad $12/qt.
Broccoli Apple & Craisin Salad $14/qt.


Terri Lynn's Chicken Salad  $13/pound                                                                                                                                                                                                                            


(sold in half pint containers)

Orange Poppy Seed Dressing   $7

Parmesan Peppercorn Dressing  $8

Creamy Jalapeno Dressing   $7

Balsamic Vinaigrette    $7

Honey Mustard Sauce   $7

Creamy Ranch Dressing   $7

Creamy Basil Pesto Aioli   $8
Roasted Red Pepper Aioli   $9
Bourbon Barbecue Sauce   $9

Henry Bains Sauce   $10

Creamy Horseradish   $8

Christmas Pick Up Day is
Saturday December 23rd until 12 p.m.



Oven Roasted Turkey Breast

        with Pan Gravy 

$45/Family     $90/Small   $180/Large

    (serves 6)         (serves 12-15)    (serves 24-30)


Chicken Tenders

(marinated, baked and served covered in a sauce)       

$45/Family   $90/Small     $180/Large

    (15 pc.)        (30 pcs.)        (60 pcs.)

     (serves 6)         (serves 12-15)   (serves 24-30)

Kentucky Bourbon Sauce       

Cranberry Marsala Sauce

Rosemary Sauce                 

Apple Chutney Sauce    

​​Rosemary Chicken Pot Pie   

$32/Family    $65/Small   $130/Large       (serves 6)       (serves 12-15)    (serves 24-30)

Chunks of our rosemary chicken combined with celery, carrots, peas and potatoes in a thick creamy chicken broth, encased in a pastry crust


​Beef Roast in Pan Gravy with Baby Carrots

$45/family      $90/Small   $180/Large

    (serves 6)         (serves 10-12)    (serves 20-24)

Pork Tenderloin with Apple Chutney Sauce

$45/family       $90/Small  $180/Large

      (serves 6)      (serves 12-15)     (serves 24-30)

Hickory Smoked Pit Ham

with Maple Bourbon Mustard Glaze  

$35/family       $70/Small  $140/Large

       (serves 6)       (serves12-15)    (serves 24-30)

Pulled Pork Barbecue

$35/family    $70/small    $140/large

(serves 6)           (serves 12-15)     (serves 2 4-30) includes 1 dz.          includes 2 dz.        includes 4 dz.

  slider buns                slider buns             slider buns


​​Kentucky Hot Brown Casserole

Layers of toasted croutons, turkey, bacon and tomatoes in a mornay sauce topped with swiss cheese and more tomatoes.

$35/family      $70/small   $140/large 

(serves 6)            (serves 12-15)     (serves 24-30)



Family   $34​    (serves 6)   
    $65    (serves 12-15) 
Large    $130  (serves 24-30)


​Our Signature Baked Cavatappi with Chicken  

Cavatappi (curly pasta) with chunks of our seasoned chicken, spinach & sun dried tomatoes baked in a creamy parmesan sauce and topped with our three cheese blend and seasoned bread crumbs.

Baked Bowties with Roasted Butternut Squash

Mini bowtie pasta with chunks of our seasoned chicken, spinach, cremini mushrooms and roasted butternut squash  baked in a creamy parmesan sauce and topped with our three cheese blend and seasoned bread crumbs. 

Baked Rotini with Dried Cranberries and Walnuts

Rotini pasta with chunks of seasoned chicken, sweetened dried cranberries and walnuts baked in a creamy pesto sauce and topped with our three cheese blend and seasoned bread crumbs. 

Baked Creamy Penne Pumpkin & Sausage  

Penne pasta, Italian sausage tossed with a velvety pumpkin cream sauce with a hint of sage, topped with our three cheese blend, seasoned bread crumbs and toasted pumpkin seeds

Baked Penne with Meaty Marinara  

Seasoned ground beef, Italian sausage, and our zesty marinara sauce tossed with penne and topped with our three cheese blend 

​Baked Creamy Tuscan Bowties with Chicken      

Mini bowtie pasta with seasoned chicken, cremini mushrooms and spinach in a creamy sun dried tomato sauce topped with our three cheese blend and seasoned bread crumbs


Family Size (serves 6)        $20 

Small Buffet (serves 10)         $35         

Medium Buffet (serves 20)      $70        

Large Buffet (serves 40)          $140      


(All leafy salads are packed separately, so they can be assembled just prior to serving. Dressing should be served on the side.) 


Apple Pumpkin Seed Salad 

field greens with gala and granny smith apples, bleu cheese crumbles, golden raisins and toasted pumpkin

seeds served with pear poppy seed dressing

Cranberry Mandarin Pecan Salad

leafy greens topped with craisins, mandarin oranges and honey toasted pecans served with orange poppy seed dressing

Greek Salad leafy greens with grape tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, feta crumbles, kalamata olives, mild pepper rings and homemade parmesan garlic croutons served with balsamic vinaigrette  

Garden Salad

leafy greens topped with grape tomatoes, cucumbers, broccoli florets and shredded carrots served with our homemade croutons, creamy ranch or balsamic vinaigrette 

Romaine, Parmesan Grape Tomato Salad

chopped romaine, shredded parmesan, red onion slivers, grape tomatoes and home-made parmesan garlic croutons served with creamy parmesan peppercorn dressing 


Extra Croutons          $3/pint
Extra Salad Dressing    $6/half pint

bottom of page